Talk:Iga ikki/GA1

GA Review[edit]

Passed Merytat3n (talk) 03:41, 30 May 2024 (UTC)[reply]

The following discussion is closed. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page. No further edits should be made to this discussion.

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch

Nominator: 3family6 (talk · contribs) 02:03, 29 December 2023 (UTC)[reply]

Reviewer: Merytat3n (talk · contribs) 00:50, 16 May 2024 (UTC)[reply]

Looking forward to reviewing this over the next few days : ) Merytat3n (talk) 00:50, 16 May 2024 (UTC)[reply]

GA review (see here for what the criteria are, and here for what they are not)

It is reasonably well written.
a (prose, spelling, and grammar): Clearly written, just a couple of minor points:

At an approximate date of 1560, the confederacy drafted a constitution... Suggest "Around 1560..." as Serebriakova (Barducci) & Orbach (2020) say definitively "In 1560", while Man (2012) p.96 (who you don't cite for this footnote) says it was written around 1560 but probably existed earlier.

Done.--3family6 (Talk to me | See what I have done) 16:23, 18 May 2024 (UTC)[reply]

Exactly how long the document was extent and how widely it applied to the villages is unknown. I found this confusing. Do you mean "extent" as in scale and area, or "extant" as in how long it existed?

Clarified.--3family6 (Talk to me | See what I have done) 16:23, 18 May 2024 (UTC)[reply]

Sporadic guerrilla resistance continued for years and eventually was ended when Tokugawa integrated the Iga forces... I would remove "eventually".

Done.--3family6 (Talk to me | See what I have done) 16:23, 18 May 2024 (UTC)[reply]

A castle was constructed in Ueno in 1585 by Sadatsugu Tsutsui. Elsewhere in the article, the last names are consistently put first. I know the source cited puts them in the Western order but a uniform last name - first name would be good.

I missed that, corrected.--3family6 (Talk to me | See what I have done) 16:23, 18 May 2024 (UTC)[reply]

The newly added Purported Tokugawa escape through Iga section needs trimming I think. It is interesting but it seems too detailed and a bit out of scope of the article. The info given is kind of null - its true but its debated but it might not have been that route at all. I feel it could be summarised considerably, or if necessary kept as a note. I would remove the heading "Purported Tokugawa escape". I would keep the first little paragraph of that section. The sentence about the oniwaban could be kept as Samurai: An Encyclopedia of Japan's Cultured Warriors says they were called Iga mono even though they were from Kii Province. I'm not a subject matter expert though so let me know what you think : ) Merytat3n (talk) 23:24, 22 May 2024 (UTC)[reply]

Trimmed. Please let me know what you think of it now.--3family6 (Talk to me | See what I have done) 01:05, 24 May 2024 (UTC)[reply]

Looks good! Final thing: in "Edo period activities", it's mostly cultural things happening in Iga, except for the last two sentences which is about combat - both outside of Iga. I know its elaborated on in the "Further information" link but it might be worth throwing in a sentence (or 2) mentioning Iga were Edo castle guards, and that they were involved in x-battles, ending with the existing 1637 Shimabara Rebellion and 1853 Perry mentions. Let me know if this would be appropriate. Merytat3n (talk) 03:57, 25 May 2024 (UTC)[reply]

Done!--3family6 (Talk to me | See what I have done) 17:17, 26 May 2024 (UTC)[reply]

b (MoS for lead, layout, word choice, fiction, and lists):
It is factually accurate and verifiable, as shown by a source spot-check. Spot-checked using Man (2012), Serebriakova & Orbach (2020), Maltsev (2021)
a (reference section):
The authors of Irregular Warfare in Late Medieval Japan: Towards a Historical Understanding of the “Ninja” are cited here as Barducci & Orbach (2020) but their names are listed on the paper as Serebriakova & Orbach (2020).

Ah, I think Serebriakova changed her last name to Barducci - the citation generator pulled from her name as given in Academia.edu rather than in the paper. Corrected.--3family6 (Talk to me | See what I have done) 16:23, 18 May 2024 (UTC)[reply]

b (inline citations to reliable sources):

c (OR):

d (copyvio and plagiarism): Earwig comes back at 27% so no real worries. Some three or four word phrases. The longest phrases are things like to discuss issues of governance and cooperation and positioned in a village or camp.
It is broad in its coverage.
a (major aspects): b (focused):
It follows the neutral point of view policy.
Fair representation without bias:
It is stable.
No edit wars, etc.:
It is illustrated by images and other media, where possible and appropriate.
a (images are tagged and non-free content have non-free use rationales): All appropriate but Sawayama map and Battle of Nagashima could use US public domain tags

Done.--3family6 (Talk to me | See what I have done) 16:23, 18 May 2024 (UTC)[reply]

b (appropriate use with suitable captions):
Overall:
Pass/Fail: Thanks for your patience. Good work! Merytat3n (talk) 02:54, 27 May 2024 (UTC)[reply]

Merytat3n I've addressed these issues. Thank you so much!--3family6 (Talk to me | See what I have done) 16:23, 18 May 2024 (UTC)[reply]

i feel somewhat the name of Iga ikki were quite problematic here.. aside as i didnt find the counterpart in Japanese wikipedia, Ikki means rebellion, in japan. so i dont think its proper name describe a political confederacy that coexist with Tokugawa shogunate until its dissolution. not to mention the Shogunate and Todo Takatora also employ them as Oniwaban which is equivalent with secret police institute. previously, i didnt address this issue, but since now there's GA nomination review, i think its proper time to address it Ahendra (talk) 18:26, 18 May 2024 (UTC)[reply]

Hi @Ahendra: I think that if you had an issue with the name of the article, you should have addressed it on the talk page at the time instead of interrupting a GA review by adding a lot of new content to the article and wanting to discuss a name change : ) I suggest you make a new topic on the talk page and discuss it there instead of inside the GA review space. Merytat3n (talk) 03:37, 19 May 2024 (UTC)[reply]

Ahendra It's referred to as an ikki by multiple academic sources, and it is not the only quasi-state to be referred to as such. For instance, Kaga ikki and Yamashiro ikki. Ikki does mean rebellion but came to also refer to rebel-held areas. "aside as i didnt find the counterpart in Japanese wikipedia". It's a redlink, currently. I created this article for the English Wikipedia fairly recently, apparently no-one on the Japanese wiki has created an article yet for this entity. Furthermore, the redlink has "Ichire" has part of the title, which also means revolt.--3family6 (Talk to me | See what I have done) 00:40, 20 May 2024 (UTC)[reply]

okay then, if its what academic paper mentioned Ahendra (talk) 04:48, 20 May 2024 (UTC)[reply]

The discussion above is closed. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page. No further edits should be made to this discussion.